Score: 2

"Ugh."

submission: Smokey gets Busted

date: September 17, 2005

Boring. Cliched. Unoriginal. Predictable. Short.

You aren't getting any better.

Score: 2

"Not very entertaining"

submission: My Tear for London

date: July 7, 2005

If you had worked harder on making this something more than it is at the moment, I may consider it as a better cartoon. At the moment, it's just something that says what I already know about what happened in London. It didn't leave me very entertained, or affected emotionally. I didn't think it was very good, and I don't feel like it deserves an instant 10 just because it's based on an event that hurt so many people. I'm not saying that I don't care about what happened in London, I definitely think it's a horrible thing to happen, but that, as I've said, does not instantly make this worth more than it would be if it was about something fictional.

Score: 3

"Not useful for prank calls."

submission: Anchorman Soundboard

date: June 29, 2005

I believe that the point of soundboards overall is to be able to use them for prank calls. This one, is not good for that. The sound quality is horrible, not only because of the fuzziness, but because there is music in the background for many of these. The quotes are also not good. There is no "hello" sound, no "I'm Ron Burgundy" sound, and no "goodbye" sound. Also, there just isn't a good variety of quotes. I don't care if you weren't able to make a better soundboard, because if that were true, you shouldn't have made one at all.

Score: 8

"Very good."

submission: Zelda's PRIDE force

date: May 30, 2005

One minor nitpick is that it's not the same Link in every game in the series. Only some games(such as OOT and MM) have the same Link.

Score: 1

"Creativity? What the hell is that?"

submission: JohnnyTheHomicidalManiac

date: March 19, 2005

First, the intro is a ripoff of the intro for the official Lenore flash series. Second, you used music off of Invader Zim for the background music. Also, your voice for Nny sucked. Although, it was probably just your regular speaking voice, so I guess that's not your fault.

Score: 7

"I'll give it a seven."

submission: The Most Annoying Flash

date: March 8, 2005

The only thing I don't like about this flash is that you think that the person who made Numa Numa Dance made it so that it would become a fad and take over Newgrounds. It's just something that he made and somehow it got popular. Besides that, I liked it, especially with things like Napoleon saying "A friggin' twelve gauge, what do you think?" and then shooting himself with it.

Score: 10

"Great stuff."

submission: 8-Bitch5: EvilOnTheAttack

date: January 22, 2005

A very accurate portrayal of flash 8-Bit Theater movies.

Score: 0

"You made a mistake."

submission: Piconjo: Not So Epic Kiss

date: December 4, 2004

Legendary Frog doesn't have red hair.

Score: 8

"Good, but not without complaints."

submission: Auf Achse

date: November 1, 2004

Starting off, I will say this was animated very well, and the story was done good too, but besides that I didn't like it. You didn't seem to understand what the song was talking about. In the video, you depict the guy not being able to get to the girl, although it seems that she likes him too. The song is about the guy wanting the girl, but the girl doesn't like him, and won't let him try to be with her.

I would have enjoyed this more if you had chosen another song, or reworked it to match the point of the song.

Score: 8

"I don't think Foamy is meant to be taken serious."

submission: Foamy Fan Mail 6

date: September 30, 2004

I used to think all of the Foamy rants were expressing illwill's own personal opinion, but now I think it's all a joke, and Foamy is supposed to be viewed as an idiot. Once I came to this realization, I found this flash to be very funny. Foamy is a very engaging character when you realize he's supposed to be a dipshit. Even funnier is the fact that Foamy has managed to twist the opinions of others, swearing Foamy as the next savior.

My hat is off to you, illwill, for fooling an online community.